From 2d0121cd730837c1b36dd495bbdaaa96e46a8e85 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Claude Date: Fri, 15 May 2026 19:18:48 +0000 Subject: [PATCH 1/2] board hygiene tail: post-merge governance for PR #372 MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit Per CLAUDE.md Mandatory Board-Hygiene Rule, post-merge updates for the canonical board state. All 5 files updated: PR_ARC_INVENTORY.md: PREPEND PR #372 entry (Added / Locked / Deferred / Docs / Confidence sections per format) above #366. LATEST_STATE.md: PREPEND row for PR #372 in Recently Shipped table; update Last-updated metadata line with PR #372 summary and the three major findings (dual CausalEdge64, p64 drift origin, three-zone hot path); add Contract Inventory section for the dual CausalEdge64 types. EPIPHANIES.md: PREPEND E-META-7 dated 2026-05-14 covering the three coupled findings — dual CausalEdge64 types, p64 drift origin pinpointed at convergence.rs:18-22 #[allow(unused_imports)] annotation, three-zone hot-path mental model. TYPE_DUPLICATION_MAP.md: APPEND section #13 documenting CausalEdge64 as 2 distinct types in workspace (NOT a candidate for direct dedup; they represent different cognitive operations). Includes the 8-channel to SPO transcoding mapping (Option R-3) and the drift-origin reference. STATUS_BOARD.md: APPEND causaledge64-mailbox-rename-soa-v1 plan section with 13 D-CE64-MB-* / D-SPRINT-10-* spec-shipped rows + 15 sprint-11 implementation rows (all Queued, with per-row blockers cited) + 4 user-ratification gates (CSI-1 + OQ-1/3/5) + 6 reunification track items (D-REUNIFY-1..6) tracking the sprint-12+ Think carrier struct unification arc. D-REUNIFY-1 (acknowledge dual CausalEdge64 in board files) is marked Shipped by this very commit. https://claude.ai/code/session_01UwJuKqP828qyX1VkLgGJFS --- .claude/board/EPIPHANIES.md | 28 +++++++++++++ .claude/board/LATEST_STATE.md | 9 ++++- .claude/board/PR_ARC_INVENTORY.md | 61 +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ .claude/board/STATUS_BOARD.md | 65 +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ docs/TYPE_DUPLICATION_MAP.md | 31 +++++++++++++++ 5 files changed, 193 insertions(+), 1 deletion(-) diff --git a/.claude/board/EPIPHANIES.md b/.claude/board/EPIPHANIES.md index 02f4952b..739b1f1e 100644 --- a/.claude/board/EPIPHANIES.md +++ b/.claude/board/EPIPHANIES.md @@ -65,6 +65,34 @@ stay as historical references. ## Entries (reverse chronological) +## 2026-05-14 — E-META-7 (FINDING): dual `CausalEdge64` types in workspace + p64 drift origin pinpointed + three-zone hot-path model + +**Status:** FINDING (verified 2026-05-14 against shipped source; recorded in PR #372 merge commit `9fa206d`). + +Three coupled findings surfaced during sprint-10 meta-review + post-research correction of the hot-path mental model. + +**1. Dual `CausalEdge64` types** (not in `docs/TYPE_DUPLICATION_MAP.md` prior to this entry): +- `causal_edge::CausalEdge64` at `crates/causal-edge/src/edge.rs:60` — SPO-palette layout (S/P/O palette indices + NARS f/c + Pearl 2³ mask + direction + inference type + plasticity + temporal) +- `thinking_engine::layered::CausalEdge64` at `crates/thinking-engine/src/layered.rs:45` — 8-channel cascade (BECOMES / CAUSES / SUPPORTS / REFINES / GROUNDS / ABSTRACTS / RELATES / CONTRADICTS, each 1 byte) + +Same name, different bit semantics, different consumers. Reunification path = Option R-3 (transcode 8-channel → SPO at L3 commit). See `.claude/knowledge/causal-edge-64-spo-variant.md` + `.claude/knowledge/causal-edge-64-thinking-engine-variant.md` + `.claude/knowledge/causal-edge-64-synergies-and-pr-trajectory.md`. + +**2. p64 drift origin pinpointed.** `crates/lance-graph-planner/src/cache/convergence.rs:18-22`: +```rust +#[allow(unused_imports)] // CausalEdge64 intended for hot-path convergence wiring +use super::nars_engine::{CausalEdge64, SpoHead, MASK_SPO}; +``` +The convergence wiring was started and never finished. The `nars_engine::CausalEdge64` re-export is the SPO-palette variant; the thinking-engine 8-channel variant was reinvented locally at `crates/thinking-engine/src/layered.rs:45` instead of imported here. **This `#[allow(unused_imports)]` annotation is the smoking gun** for where the dual-variant drift formalized. + +**3. Three-zone hot-path mental model** (corrects "AriGraph reads = µs cold-path joins" framing): +- **Zone-1** (cycle-speed, 200-500 ns): thinking-engine MatVec → top-k atoms → `emit_causal_edges` 8-channel emission; AriGraph `entity_index: HashMap>` lookup is O(1) ~20-200 ns (NOT cold). +- **Zone-2** (SPO-as-3D-vector ANN, 20-1200 µs): blasgraph + neighborhood cascade HEEL → HIP → TWIG → LEAF via `zeckf64()`. +- **Zone-3** (DataFusion cold path, >1 ms): `lance-graph-planner` columnar joins for offline analytics; NOT touched by cognitive dispatch. + +Cross-ref: `.claude/knowledge/cognitive-shader-driver-thinking-engine-reunification.md` (5-step reunification plan); `.claude/knowledge/splat-shader-rayon-struct-method-vision.md` (sprint-12+ 5-sprint arc). + +--- + ## 2026-05-14 — E-CE64-MB-1..10: CausalEdge64-mailbox + sparse-rename composition (10 epiphanies) 10 epiphanies from the recursive-fresh-eyes architectural pass culminating in `.claude/plans/causaledge64-mailbox-rename-soa-v1.md`. Branch: `claude/resolve-pr-369-conflicts-ozMXd`. PR #370 in flight. Each epiphany is composition, not invention — every piece had existing plan/spec authoring before this session. diff --git a/.claude/board/LATEST_STATE.md b/.claude/board/LATEST_STATE.md index 61e6be8f..11f12c20 100644 --- a/.claude/board/LATEST_STATE.md +++ b/.claude/board/LATEST_STATE.md @@ -2,7 +2,7 @@ > **Auto-injected at session start via SessionStart hook.** > Updated after every merged PR. -> **Last updated:** 2026-05-13 (PR #366 merged: sprint-7 7-worker implementation wave for the sprint-5/6 specs + AuditSink trait unification, ~5 KLOC across 5 crates +2 new (`lance-graph-supervisor`, `lance-graph-consumer-conformance`), ~70 new tests, workspace clippy --tests --no-deps -D warnings exits 0; Opus meta verdict 4A/2B/1B-minus; OQ-7-1/2/3 all locked pre-merge; `UnifiedAuditSink` D-SDR-4 placeholder dropped, all sinks unified on `AuditSink` trait; `UnifiedBridge::with_jsonl_audit()` ergonomic constructor added for MedCare-rs sprint-2 item 5. **Adjacent landings (same day):** MedCare-rs sprint-1 10-PR sweep (#113-#122) including E1-1 OQ-3 direct migration (6 RoleGroups) consuming our `0d725d4` decision. MedCare-rs sprint-2 (5 PRs) is queued on user "go" — item 5 consumes this PR's new constructor. Prior same-day: PR #365 (13 sprint-5/6 specs + meta). Prior: PR #364 (D-SDR-3/4/5 + sprint-log-4 governance + sprint-5-9 roadmap + codex P1/P2 fixes). lance-graph #364 ships D-SDR-3/4/5 + sprint-log-4 governance + sprint-5-9 roadmap + codex P1/P2 surgical fixes (OwlIdentity 3-byte canonical, UnifiedAuditEvent 26 bytes, OgitFamilyTable sparse `HashMap`, audit super_domain via AuditChain). MedCare-rs#112 (PR-B) wires `UnifiedBridge` + medcare-rbac + medcare-realtime substrate (+2963 LOC, 17 files, §73 SGB V + BMV-Ä §57 + BtM regulatory tests). smb-office-rs#31 (PR-C) wires `UnifiedBridge` (+111 LOC). ndarray#142 ships VBMI gate for `permute_bytes` (P0 SIGILL fix on Skylake-X / Cascade Lake / Ice Lake-SP) + Inf clamp for `simd_exp_f32`. D-SDR-5 `UnifiedBridge` surface is now consumed end-to-end across MedCare + smb-office. Prior: 2026-05-07 (PR #354). Prior: 2026-05-07 (PR #353). Prior: 2026-05-07 (PR #352). Prior: 2026-05-06 (splat-osint-ingestion-v1 PR 1+2 of 6 in flight). Prior: 2026-04-21 post PR #243. +> **Last updated:** 2026-05-14 (PR #372 merged: sprint-10 spec sprint, 12-worker CCA2A fleet + Opus meta-review + 8 knowledge docs, governance-only (zero .rs changes), mirrors PR #365 pattern. Sprint-11 implementation wave gated on 5 spec patches + 4 user ratifications: CSI-1 CausalEdge64 bit-reclaim Option, OQ-1 Σ4-Σ5 banding, OQ-3 plasticity granularity, OQ-5 rayon vendor. **Major findings:** (1) dual `CausalEdge64` types in workspace — `causal_edge::CausalEdge64` SPO-palette layout ≠ `thinking_engine::layered::CausalEdge64` 8-channel cascade, same name different semantics, surfaced as duplication entry #13 in TYPE_DUPLICATION_MAP and E-META-7 in EPIPHANIES; (2) p64 drift origin pinpointed at `crates/lance-graph-planner/src/cache/convergence.rs:18-22 #[allow(unused_imports)]` annotation — wiring intended for hot-path convergence never finished; (3) three-zone hot-path mental model corrects prior framing — Zone-1 thinking-engine MatVec 200-500ns + AriGraph entity_index O(1) ~20-200ns is the actual cycle-speed path, not DataFusion. Prior: 2026-05-13 (PR #366 merged: sprint-7 7-worker implementation wave for the sprint-5/6 specs + AuditSink trait unification, ~5 KLOC across 5 crates +2 new (`lance-graph-supervisor`, `lance-graph-consumer-conformance`), ~70 new tests, workspace clippy --tests --no-deps -D warnings exits 0; Opus meta verdict 4A/2B/1B-minus; OQ-7-1/2/3 all locked pre-merge; `UnifiedAuditSink` D-SDR-4 placeholder dropped, all sinks unified on `AuditSink` trait; `UnifiedBridge::with_jsonl_audit()` ergonomic constructor added for MedCare-rs sprint-2 item 5. **Adjacent landings (same day):** MedCare-rs sprint-1 10-PR sweep (#113-#122) including E1-1 OQ-3 direct migration (6 RoleGroups) consuming our `0d725d4` decision. MedCare-rs sprint-2 (5 PRs) is queued on user "go" — item 5 consumes this PR's new constructor. Prior same-day: PR #365 (13 sprint-5/6 specs + meta). Prior: PR #364 (D-SDR-3/4/5 + sprint-log-4 governance + sprint-5-9 roadmap + codex P1/P2 fixes). lance-graph #364 ships D-SDR-3/4/5 + sprint-log-4 governance + sprint-5-9 roadmap + codex P1/P2 surgical fixes (OwlIdentity 3-byte canonical, UnifiedAuditEvent 26 bytes, OgitFamilyTable sparse `HashMap`, audit super_domain via AuditChain). MedCare-rs#112 (PR-B) wires `UnifiedBridge` + medcare-rbac + medcare-realtime substrate (+2963 LOC, 17 files, §73 SGB V + BMV-Ä §57 + BtM regulatory tests). smb-office-rs#31 (PR-C) wires `UnifiedBridge` (+111 LOC). ndarray#142 ships VBMI gate for `permute_bytes` (P0 SIGILL fix on Skylake-X / Cascade Lake / Ice Lake-SP) + Inf clamp for `simd_exp_f32`. D-SDR-5 `UnifiedBridge` surface is now consumed end-to-end across MedCare + smb-office. Prior: 2026-05-07 (PR #354). Prior: 2026-05-07 (PR #353). Prior: 2026-05-07 (PR #352). Prior: 2026-05-06 (splat-osint-ingestion-v1 PR 1+2 of 6 in flight). Prior: 2026-04-21 post PR #243. > > Purpose: prevent new sessions from hallucinating structure that > already exists or proposing features already shipped. Read this @@ -14,6 +14,7 @@ | PR | Merged | Title | What it added | |---|---|---|---| +| **#372** | 2026-05-14 | specs(sprint-10): 12-worker CCA2A fleet + meta-review (governance only) | Sprint-10 spec sprint mirroring PR #365 pattern (specs precede a separate implementation wave). **38 .md files / ~580 KB / zero .rs changes.** 11 PR-ready worker specs (~370 KB) covering par-tile crate apex, CausalEdge64 v2 layout, BindSpace E/F/G/H columns, AriGraph SPO-G + ghost edges + SpoWitnessChain, MailboxSoA + AttentionMaskActor, SigmaTierRouter + banding + plasticity + KernelHandle cache, bevy cull plugin, ndarray Miri completion, sprint-10 execution plan, PR dep graph, unified test plan. Opus meta-review (~28 KB) with sprint grade B+, 6 cross-spec inconsistencies (CSI-1..6), 5 cross-cutting epiphanies (E-META-1..5), sprint-11 spawn decision = NO until 5 spec patches + 4 user ratifications. 8 knowledge docs (~123 KB) documenting: **dual `CausalEdge64` finding** (SPO-palette variant in `causal-edge` crate ≠ 8-channel cascade variant in `thinking-engine` crate, same name different bit semantics); **p64 drift origin** pinpointed at `crates/lance-graph-planner/src/cache/convergence.rs:18-22 #[allow(unused_imports)]`; **three-zone hot-path model** (Zone-1 thinking-engine MatVec 200-500ns + AriGraph entity_index O(1), Zone-2 blasgraph+neighborhood cascade 20-1200µs, Zone-3 DataFusion >1ms); **SPOW tetrahedron + ontology-aware splat vision**; **5-sprint reunification arc** to unify thinking-engine + cognitive-shader-driver SoA. **Deferred:** sprint-11 implementation wave, `Think` carrier struct unification (sprint-12+), splat shader op fleet (sprint-13+), OWL DOLCE / OntologyFilter wiring (sprint-12+), PR-J1-INT4-32D-ATOMS as Wave 0.5 prerequisite. | | **#366** | 2026-05-13 | impl(sprint-7): 7-worker implementation wave + AuditSink trait unification | Sprint-7 CCA2A 6-parallel + 1-sequenced + 1-Opus-meta. **~5 KLOC across 5 crates + 2 new** (`lance-graph-supervisor`, `lance-graph-consumer-conformance`). Workers: **S7-W1** `parse_family_registry()` + Healthcare basins `0x10..=0x19` (unblocks MedCare-rs E1-2/E1-3/E1-4 cascade); **S7-W2** `lance-graph-contract/build.rs` codegen (zero-dep preserved; sorted-slice + binary_search, no phf — OQ-2); **S7-W3** ractor supervisor with separate 18-byte `LifecycleAuditEvent` (CC-2) + `SuperDomain::System` exempt (CC-3); **S7-W4** `assert_consumer_conformance` harness (A1-A10); **S7-W5** `CognitiveBridgeGate` trait + `UnifiedBridgeGate` impl; **S7-W6** new `audit_sink/` module (`AuditSink` trait + `JsonlAuditSink` + `LanceAuditSink` + `CompositeSink`) + `audit_verify` CLI + `prev_merkle` field on UnifiedAuditEvent (canonical_bytes still 26 B); **S7-W7** SMB Foundry `0x80..=0x82` vs BSON `0xA0..=0xAD` disjoint slots (OQ-4). **Post-meta AuditSink trait unification** (`bc530a4`): dropped legacy `UnifiedAuditSink` D-SDR-4 placeholder, `UnifiedBridge::audit_sink: Arc`, added `with_jsonl_audit()` ergonomic constructor (OQ-7-2 + OQ-7-3 locked). **Pre-existing workspace lint debt** cleaned by Sonnet janitor across ~30 files in `lance-graph` core / `bgz-tensor` / planner / nsm (sprint-7 outputs guardrailed). **Opus meta verdict** at `.claude/board/sprint-log-7/meta-review.md`: 4A/2B/1B-minus/0 C/D/F. **Adjacent landings:** MedCare-rs sprint-1 10-PR sweep #113-#122 (E1-1 OQ-3 consumed our `0d725d4` decision; sprint-2 5 PRs queued). | | **#365** | 2026-05-13 | specs(sprint-5-6): 13-worker parallel batch + Opus meta review | Governance-only PR. **13 PR-ready specs at `.claude/specs/`** (~300 KB) from a 12-Sonnet-worker + 1-post-meta-Sonnet-worker + 1-Opus-meta-agent parallel batch. Spec grades: 3 A (W2 d3b-jsonl, W5 pr-graph, W12 conformance), 7 B, 2 C (W10 manifest-modules needs §4.3 sorted-slice rewrite; W11 ractor-supervisor needs LifecycleAuditEvent split). 24 KB Opus meta cross-spec review at `.claude/board/sprint-log-5-6/meta-review.md`. 4 blocking OQs (W3 parser entry, W10 phf vs sorted-slice, W6 Role migration, W13 BSON namespace). CCA2A 12+1+1 pattern validated at scale: ~300 KB of PR-ready output in under an hour wall-clock; 3 workers required respawns for permission denials (settings.json patched for `.claude/board/sprint-log-5-6/**`). | | **#364** | 2026-05-13 | D-SDR-3/4/5 + sprint-log-4 governance + sprint 5-9 roadmap + codex P1/P2 | Tier-A substrate close: **D-SDR-3** OgitFamilyTable + FamilyEntry codebook (~300 LOC), **D-SDR-4** merkle-chained UnifiedAuditEvent (~460 LOC, AuditMerkleRoot = u64 FNV-1a), **D-SDR-5** authorize_* through Policy::evaluate with audit emission (~300 LOC). **Codex P1 fix** (`3208743`): OwlIdentity widened u8→u16 slot → 3-byte canonical `[family, slot_lo, slot_hi]`; OgitFamilyTable → sparse `HashMap`; UnifiedAuditEvent canonical_bytes 25→26. **Codex P2 fix** (`e23ce89`): emit_audit uses AuditChain.super_domain() instead of static FAMILY_TO_SUPER_DOMAIN. **CI fix** (`a3c753f`): ndarray/hpc-extras opt-in for blake3. Sprint-log-4 governance corpus (12 worker specs + 2 meta reviews) + sprint-5-through-9 roadmap (70 agents = 60W + 10M across 5 sprints, mandatory 12-step plan-read-order in worker prompts). 97/97 callcenter lib tests pass. All 5 CI checks green on `c8176cb`. Adjacent: ndarray#142 (VBMI gate + Inf clamp) merged same day. | @@ -43,6 +44,12 @@ Types that EXIST — do NOT re-propose them: **`cognitive-shader-driver` BindSpace substrate (2026-04-24)**: `FingerprintColumns.cycle` is now `Box<[f32]>` (Vsa16kF32 carrier, 16_384 f32 per row = 64 KB) — migrated from `Box<[u64]>` (Binary16K). New constant `FLOATS_PER_VSA = 16_384`. New methods: `set_cycle(&[f32])`, `set_cycle_from_bits(&[u64; 256])` (adapter with `binary16k_to_vsa16k_bipolar` projection), `cycle_row() -> &[f32]`. `write_cycle_fingerprint()` API unchanged (takes `&[u64; 256]`), converts internally. `byte_footprint()` for 1 row = 71_774 bytes. Other three planes (content/topic/angle) remain `Box<[u64]>`. +**CausalEdge64 — TWO distinct types in workspace (2026-05-14, PR #372 finding)**: same name, different bit semantics, different consumers. Always qualify by crate when referring to either: +- `causal_edge::CausalEdge64` (`crates/causal-edge/src/edge.rs:60`) — SPO-palette layout: S/P/O palette indices + NARS f/c + Pearl 2³ mask + direction triad + inference type + plasticity flags + temporal index. Consumed by `lance-graph-planner::cache::nars_engine` (NarsTables), `cognitive-shader-driver::BindSpace::EdgeColumn`, AriGraph SPO commit path. The unit of NARS reasoning at cycle-speed. +- `thinking_engine::layered::CausalEdge64` (`crates/thinking-engine/src/layered.rs:45`) — 8-channel cascade: BECOMES / CAUSES / SUPPORTS / REFINES / GROUNDS / ABSTRACTS / RELATES / CONTRADICTS (each 1 byte). Source/target NOT in u64 (carried as tuple key `(target: u16, edge: CausalEdge64)`). Emitted by `TierEngine::emit_causal_edges` after MatVec; consumed by downstream tiers via `apply_edges`. The unit of cognitive-cascade dispatch in the L1 → L2 → L3 thinking pipeline. + +Full reference: `.claude/knowledge/causal-edge-64-spo-variant.md` + `.claude/knowledge/causal-edge-64-thinking-engine-variant.md` + `.claude/knowledge/causal-edge-64-synergies-and-pr-trajectory.md`. Reunification path (Option R-3): transcode 8-channel → SPO at thinking-engine L3 commit boundary; see `.claude/knowledge/cognitive-shader-driver-thinking-engine-reunification.md`. + ## cognitive-shader-driver Wire Surface (lab-only, post D0.1) Types live in `crates/cognitive-shader-driver/src/wire.rs` behind `--features serve`: diff --git a/.claude/board/PR_ARC_INVENTORY.md b/.claude/board/PR_ARC_INVENTORY.md index eb53fb6b..e4c222b7 100644 --- a/.claude/board/PR_ARC_INVENTORY.md +++ b/.claude/board/PR_ARC_INVENTORY.md @@ -35,6 +35,67 @@ --- +## #372 — specs(sprint-10): 12-worker CCA2A fleet + meta-review (governance only) (merged 2026-05-14) + +**Confidence (2026-05-14):** governance-only merged clean (no `.rs` changes; CI N/A for spec-only PR). **Status:** Merged to `main` (commit `9fa206d`). Mirrors PR #365 pattern (spec sprint preceding a future implementation wave; sprint-11 = implementation, blocked on user ratifications). 7 commits on the merged branch: 3 themed this session (`5c68a2e` specs + `abc2706` board hygiene + `11ae222` knowledge docs) + 4 prior scaffolding commits. + +**Added:** +- **11 PR-ready sprint-10 worker specs** (~370 KB) at `.claude/specs/`: + - **W1** `pr-ce64-mb-1-par-tile-crate` — new substrate crate `par-tile`, `Mailbox` trait + 3 backings (Tokio / InMem / SupabaseSub), `AttentionMask` SoA with LRU eviction, `BindSpaceView` via `NonNull` (dep-isolation), dep-guard build.rs. ~1425 LOC source + 540 LOC tests. + - **W2** `pr-ce64-mb-2-causaledge64-v2` — proposed v2 layout with G/W/truth-band lens; **OQ-LAYOUT-1 BLOCKER** finding (parent plan §3 "13 reserved bits 51-63" don't exist in shipped `edge.rs`); 5 reclaim options (A-E) for user ratification. + - **W3** `pr-ce64-mb-2-pal8-nars-regression` — defensive functional tests (accessor-based, not bit-positional) → remain valid post-OQ-LAYOUT-1 regardless of which Option ratifies. + - **W4** `pr-ce64-mb-3-bindspace-efgh` — BindSpace columns E/F/G/H, Column H entity_type already wired (PR #272), MergeMode::Superposition documented; AwareOp D-F4/D-F5 stubbed as no-op (deferred to sprint-12+). + - **W5** `pr-ce64-mb-4-arigraph-spo-g` — Triplet schema extension with `g: u32`, `pearl_rung: u8`, `witness_ref: u64`; new `ghost.rs` module (GhostStore + GhostReactivationEvent + nars_revise_ghosts); `SpoWitness64` (Copy, 8 B) + `SpoWitnessChain<32>`; SCHEMA_VERSION 2→3 migration. + - **W6** `pr-ce64-mb-5-mailbox-soa-attentionmask` — `MailboxSoA` + `AttentionMaskActor` (single tick per cycle invariant); 9 tests + sequence diagram + risk matrix. + - **W7** `pr-ce64-mb-6-sigma-tier-router` — `SigmaTierRouter` ractor actor (6 msg variants) + 10-tier banding table + INT4-32D K-NN cold-start fallback + Hebbian plasticity rollup at drop_row + 3-trigger pruning + `KernelHandleCache` (closes THINKING_ORCHESTRATION_WIRING.md Gap 3) + Σ9-Σ10 EPIPHANY escalation with 1024-entry backpressure. 30 tests, 4 benches. + - **W8** `pr-ndarray-miri-complete` — Miri coverage growth target: ~760 → ~1550 (3 mechanisms across ndarray + new pure-Rust crates + expanded lance-graph Miri scope). + - **W9** `pr-ce64-mb-7-bevy-cull-plugin` — bevy 0.14 cull plugin proof-PR; producer-side cull_system + spawn_system + 12 tests + 4 benches. + - **W10** `sprint-10-pr-dep-graph` — 8 PRs across 6 waves with parallel-landability table + 6 cross-spec consistency checks (C-1..C-6). + - **W11** `sprint-10-test-plan` — unified test plan + Miri growth target + proptest Miri runtime guidance. + - **W12** `sprint-10-execution-plan` — sprint-11 fleet definition + post-merge governance + worker prompt template (CCA2A protocol). +- **Sprint-10 Opus meta-review** (~28 KB) at `.claude/board/sprint-log-10/meta-review.md`: + - Sprint grade: **B+** (substrate-level CausalEdge64 plan/code-gap finding = CSI-1, the central value-add) + - Per-worker grades: W2/W3/W5/W8/W10/W11/W12 = A/A−; W1/W6/W7/W9 = B+; W4 = B− + - **6 cross-spec inconsistencies (CSI-1..CSI-6)** surfaced with resolution paths; 3 are BLOCKERs for sprint-11 spawn (CSI-1 user ratification; CSI-2 W6 CompartmentReport patch; CSI-3 W10 dep-graph PR-J1 prerequisite) + - **5 cross-cutting epiphanies (E-META-1..E-META-5)**: specs-against-source > specs-against-plan; late-spec coordination gap; scratchpad discipline bimodal; 4 BindSpace columns + Σ-tier band = AGI-as-glove API; diamond dep graph holds + - Sprint-11 spawn decision: **NO** until 5 spec patches + 4 user ratifications (CSI-1 + parent plan OQ-1/3/5) + - Adjusted wave sequence: add Wave 0.5 `PR-J1-INT4-32D-ATOMS` before Wave 1 +- **11 sprint-log-10 worker scratchpads** at `.claude/board/sprint-log-10/agents/agent-W{1..12}.md` (W3 was prior-committed at `6fd4e8c`) — CCA2A Layer-2 blackboard artifacts; each itemizes mandatory reads + design decisions + OQs surfaced. +- **8 knowledge docs** (~123 KB) at `.claude/knowledge/`: + - `causal-edge-64-spo-variant.md` — `causal-edge::CausalEdge64` (SPO-palette layout: S/P/O palette + NARS f/c + Pearl mask + direction + inference + plasticity + temporal) + - `causal-edge-64-thinking-engine-variant.md` — `thinking_engine::layered::CausalEdge64` (8 channels × 8 bits: BECOMES / CAUSES / SUPPORTS / REFINES / GROUNDS / ABSTRACTS / RELATES / CONTRADICTS) + - `causal-edge-64-synergies-and-pr-trajectory.md` — what each variant does BETTER + thinking-engine function mapping + reunification Options R-1 (CausalEdge128) / R-2 (paired tuple) / R-3 (transcode at L3 commit, recommended) + - `spo-schema-and-mailbox-sidecar.md` — SPO-G vs SPO-W (witness tetrahedron per oxigraph-arigraph plan §8) vs both; time-as-sidecar correction; ractor mailbox payload per Σ-tier + - `spo-ontology-format-stack.md` — 3×16Kbit → ZeckBF17 → Base17 → PaletteEdge/CAM-PQ → Scent → CausalEdge64 ladder with selection matrix + - `ogit-owl-dolce-ontology-compartments.md` — OGIT (domain content) + OWL (axioms) + DOLCE (orthogonal categorical scaffold); 8-channel ↔ OWL axiom near-isomorphism (SUPPORTS↔sameAs, REFINES↔subClassOf-down, etc.) + - `cognitive-shader-driver-thinking-engine-reunification.md` — **p64 drift origin pinpointed** at `crates/lance-graph-planner/src/cache/convergence.rs:18-22 #[allow(unused_imports)]` annotation (wiring started, never finished — the smoking gun) + - `splat-shader-rayon-struct-method-vision.md` — splat ops fleet + ndarray struct methods + rayon work-stealing + computational entropy reduction + 5-sprint reunification arc +- **AGENT_ORCHESTRATION_LOG.md** modification recording the sprint-log-10 12-worker fleet run + main-thread W7/W9 backfill + meta-review. + +**Locked:** +- **Sprint-10 = the spec sprint half** of the alternating spec/implementation pattern (parallel to PR #365 sprint-5-6 specs → PR #366 sprint-7 implementation). Sprint-11 = the implementation wave (separate PR; gated on user ratifications). +- **Dual `CausalEdge64` types FINDING (E-META-7)**: `causal_edge::CausalEdge64` (SPO-palette in `crates/causal-edge/src/edge.rs:60`) ≠ `thinking_engine::layered::CausalEdge64` (8-channel cascade in `crates/thinking-engine/src/layered.rs:45`). Same name, different bit semantics, different consumers. Reunification per Option R-3 (transcode at L3 commit) recommended. +- **Three-zone hot-path mental model** (corrects prior "AriGraph reads = µs cold-path joins" framing): Zone-1 (thinking-engine MatVec 200-500 ns + AriGraph `entity_index` HashMap O(1) ~20-200 ns); Zone-2 (blasgraph + neighborhood cascade HEEL→HIP→TWIG→LEAF, 20-1200 µs); Zone-3 (DataFusion / lance-graph-planner cold path, >1 ms). +- **p64 convergence drift origin** pinpointed at `crates/lance-graph-planner/src/cache/convergence.rs:18-22` — the `#[allow(unused_imports)] // CausalEdge64 intended for hot-path convergence wiring` annotation is the smoking gun. Wiring started, never finished; thinking-engine's 8-channel variant was reinvented locally (`crates/thinking-engine/src/layered.rs:45`) instead of imported here. +- **CCA2A 12-worker pattern** validated at sprint-10 scale: 11 worker specs + 1 meta-review across 12 Sonnet workers + 1 Opus meta in parallel, with 2 main-thread backfill specs (W7 + W9) for workers not spawned. Worker scratchpads = CCA2A Layer-2 blackboard. +- **Meta-review-first sprint discipline**: surface CSI / OQ / cross-spec drift via Opus meta BEFORE implementation spawn; don't let drift propagate into impl PRs. + +**Deferred:** +- **Sprint-11 implementation wave** — needs 5 pre-spawn spec patches (CSI-2 through CSI-6) + 4 user ratifications (CSI-1 bit-reclaim Option + parent plan OQ-1 Σ-tier banding + OQ-3 plasticity granularity + OQ-5 rayon vendor). +- **`Think` carrier struct unification** — collapse thinking-engine cascade + cognitive-shader-driver SoA into one carrier (per `splat-shader-rayon-struct-method-vision.md` sprint-12+ 5-sprint arc). +- **Splat shader op fleet** (`splat_gaussian`, `score_hole_closure`, `replay_coherence`, `emit_if_epiphany`) — sprint-13+ per CONJECTURE in `splat-shader-rayon-struct-method-vision.md`. +- **OWL DOLCE / OntologyFilter wiring** into thinking-engine `emit_causal_edges_filtered` — sprint-12+ per `ogit-owl-dolce-ontology-compartments.md` §6. +- **PR-J1-INT4-32D-ATOMS** (codebook for sprint-11 Wave 5 SigmaTierRouter cold-start) — must land as Wave 0.5 prerequisite. + +**Docs:** +- `.claude/specs/` — 11 new sprint-10 worker specs (~370 KB). +- `.claude/board/sprint-log-10/meta-review.md` — Opus cross-spec meta-review (~28 KB). +- `.claude/board/sprint-log-10/agents/agent-W{1..12}.md` — 11 new + 1 prior-committed worker scratchpads. +- `.claude/knowledge/` — 8 new architecture reference docs (~123 KB), all with `READ BY:` headers. +- `.claude/board/AGENT_ORCHESTRATION_LOG.md` — sprint-log-10 fleet-run entry. + +--- + ## #366 — impl(sprint-7): 7-worker implementation wave for sprint-5/6 specs + AuditSink trait unification (merged 2026-05-13) **Confidence (2026-05-13):** merged clean. Workspace `cargo clippy --workspace --tests --no-deps -- -D warnings` exits 0; all sprint-7 worker tests pass; `UnifiedAuditEvent::canonical_bytes` 26-byte invariant preserved across the OQ-7-2 trait migration. **Status:** Merged to `main` (commit `3a85ec0`). **Adjacent landings (2026-05-13):** MedCare-rs sprint-1 10-PR sweep (#113 Finding 1 `MedcareOntology::from_registry` → PR-α / #114 FingerprintCodec re-export fold Pattern N → PR-γ / #115 AUTH_LEGACY_TRIPLEDES_MIGRATION cipher reality → PR-δ / #116 ALL_SCHEMAS 4→7 mirrors OGIT PR #3 → Finding 2 / #117 SPRINT5_READINESS_RECON / #118 ndarray hpc-extras investigation upstream-blocked / **#119 medcare_healthcare_policy + 6 RoleGroups consumes our `0d725d4` OQ-3 direct-migration decision** / #120 governance board + tier-0 / #121 sprint-1 meta-retrospective with §8 sprint-2 5-PR queue / #122 codex P2 path-fix). All merged the same day. MedCare-rs sprint-2 is now ready on user "go" — 5 PRs queued, item 5 (Audit-sink decision: JSONL primary + optional Lance projection) consumes this PR's `UnifiedBridge::with_jsonl_audit()` ergonomic constructor. diff --git a/.claude/board/STATUS_BOARD.md b/.claude/board/STATUS_BOARD.md index f197b330..bb8e6305 100644 --- a/.claude/board/STATUS_BOARD.md +++ b/.claude/board/STATUS_BOARD.md @@ -351,6 +351,71 @@ Cross-ref: SPLAT-1 row in `ARCHITECTURE_ENTROPY_LEDGER.md` (Aspirational → Wir --- +## causaledge64-mailbox-rename-soa-v1 — sprint-10 spec corpus + sprint-11 impl queue + +Active integration plan. Specs shipped via PR #372 (merged 2026-05-14, governance-only). +Plan path: `.claude/plans/causaledge64-mailbox-rename-soa-v1.md`. + +### Sprint-10 — spec sprint (12 CCA2A workers + Opus meta) — Shipped + +| D-id | Title | Status | PR / Evidence | +|---|---|---|---| +| D-CE64-MB-1 | par-tile crate apex + Mailbox + 3 backings + AttentionMask SoA + BindSpaceView | **Spec shipped** | #372 — `pr-ce64-mb-1-par-tile-crate.md` (W1) | +| D-CE64-MB-2 | CausalEdge64 v2 layout proposal + OQ-LAYOUT-1 BLOCKER finding | **Spec shipped** | #372 — `pr-ce64-mb-2-causaledge64-v2.md` (W2) | +| D-CE64-MB-2-regress | PAL8 / NARS regression tests (accessor-based, post-OQ-LAYOUT-1) | **Spec shipped** | #372 — `pr-ce64-mb-2-pal8-nars-regression.md` (W3) | +| D-CE64-MB-3 | BindSpace E/F/G/H column extension | **Spec shipped** | #372 — `pr-ce64-mb-3-bindspace-efgh.md` (W4) | +| D-CE64-MB-4 | AriGraph SPO-G + ghost edges + SpoWitnessChain + SCHEMA_VERSION 2→3 | **Spec shipped** | #372 — `pr-ce64-mb-4-arigraph-spo-g.md` (W5) | +| D-CE64-MB-5 | MailboxSoA + AttentionMaskActor (single tick per cycle) | **Spec shipped** | #372 — `pr-ce64-mb-5-mailbox-soa-attentionmask.md` (W6) | +| D-CE64-MB-6 | SigmaTierRouter + banding + INT4-32D cold-start + Hebbian plasticity + KernelHandle cache + Σ9-10 escalation | **Spec shipped** | #372 — `pr-ce64-mb-6-sigma-tier-router.md` (W7) | +| D-CE64-MB-7 | bevy 0.14 cull plugin proof-PR | **Spec shipped** | #372 — `pr-ce64-mb-7-bevy-cull-plugin.md` (W9) | +| D-NDARRAY-MIRI-COMPLETE | Miri coverage ~760 → ~1550 | **Spec shipped** | #372 — `pr-ndarray-miri-complete.md` (W8) | +| D-SPRINT-10-DEPGRAPH | 8 PRs × 6 waves + parallel-landability + cross-spec consistency checks | **Spec shipped** | #372 — `sprint-10-pr-dep-graph.md` (W10) | +| D-SPRINT-10-TESTPLAN | Unified test plan + Miri growth target + proptest Miri runtime | **Spec shipped** | #372 — `sprint-10-test-plan.md` (W11) | +| D-SPRINT-10-EXECPLAN | Sprint-11 fleet definition + post-merge governance + worker prompt template | **Spec shipped** | #372 — `sprint-10-execution-plan.md` (W12) | +| D-SPRINT-10-META | Opus meta-review (CSI-1..6 + E-META-1..5 + sprint-11 gate decision) | **Shipped** | #372 — `.claude/board/sprint-log-10/meta-review.md` | + +### Sprint-11 — implementation wave — Queued (blocked) + +| D-id | Title | Status | PR / Evidence | +|---|---|---|---| +| D-CE64-MB-1-impl | par-tile crate impl (W1 → code) | **Queued** | blocked on OQ-5 user ratification (rayon vendor) | +| D-CE64-MB-2-impl | CausalEdge64 v2 layout impl (W2 → code) | **Queued** | blocked on CSI-1 user ratification (which Option A/B/C/D/E for bit reclaim) | +| D-CE64-MB-2-regress-impl | PAL8 / NARS regression test impl (W3 → code) | **Queued** | blocked on D-CE64-MB-2-impl | +| D-CE64-MB-3-impl | BindSpace E/F/G/H impl (W4 → code) | **Queued** | blocked on D-CE64-MB-1-impl | +| D-CE64-MB-4-impl | AriGraph SPO-G + ghosts impl (W5 → code) | **Queued** | blocked on D-CE64-MB-2-impl | +| D-CE64-MB-5-impl | MailboxSoA + AttentionMaskActor impl (W6 → code) | **Queued** | blocked on OQ-3 user ratification (plasticity granularity) + CSI-2 spec patch (g_slot_at_drop field) | +| D-CE64-MB-6-impl | SigmaTierRouter impl (W7 → code) | **Queued** | blocked on OQ-1 user ratification (Σ4-Σ5 banding) + CSI-3 spec patch (PR-J1 Wave 0.5 prerequisite) | +| D-CE64-MB-7-impl | bevy cull plugin impl (W9 → code) | **Queued** | blocked on D-CE64-MB-1-impl + CSI-4 spec patch (BindSpaceView::empty_static() ctor in W1) | +| D-NDARRAY-MIRI-COMPLETE-impl | Miri coverage impl (W8 → code) | **Queued** | independent; can spawn first | +| D-PR-J1-INT4-32D-ATOMS | INT4-32D codebook for SigmaTierRouter cold-start | **Queued** | new Wave 0.5 prerequisite; not in original W10 dep graph | +| D-CSI-2 | W6 CompartmentReport `g_slot_at_drop: u8` field patch | **Queued** | small spec edit; pre-sprint-11 | +| D-CSI-3 | W10 dep graph PR-J1 Wave 0.5 row patch | **Queued** | small spec edit; pre-sprint-11 | +| D-CSI-4 | W1 spec `BindSpaceView::empty_static()` + `from_arc()` constructors | **Queued** | small spec edit; pre-sprint-11 | +| D-CSI-5 | W1 spec move `SigmaTier` to `lance-graph-contract::orchestration` | **Queued** | small spec edit; pre-sprint-11 | +| D-CSI-6 | W11 test-count drift reconciliation | **Queued** | small spec edit; pre-sprint-11 | + +### User-ratification gates (block sprint-11 spawn) + +| Gate | Wave blocked | Resolution path | +|---|---|---| +| **CSI-1** — CausalEdge64 bit-reclaim Option (A/B/C/D/E) | Wave 2 (D-CE64-MB-2-impl) | User picks; meta-review recommends Option C-conservative (drop temporal + G-slot, allocate W-slot + lens) | +| **OQ-1** — Σ4-Σ5 banding (Tokio reflex vs InMem cycle-speed) | Wave 5 (D-CE64-MB-6-impl) | Default Tokio is safe-to-ship; ratification only PROMOTES | +| **OQ-3** — Plasticity update granularity (bit-counter per emission + NARS revise at AriGraph commit) | Wave 4 (D-CE64-MB-5-impl) | Tentative resolution recorded; user formal-acknowledge | +| **OQ-5** — Rayon vendor decision (std::thread::scope first vs vendored-rayon) | Wave 1 (D-CE64-MB-1-impl) | Tentative defer; user formal-acknowledge | + +### Reunification track (sprint-12+) + +| D-id | Title | Status | PR / Evidence | +|---|---|---|---| +| D-REUNIFY-1 | Acknowledge dual `CausalEdge64` types in TYPE_DUPLICATION_MAP + LATEST_STATE + EPIPHANIES | **Shipped** | this commit (post-merge #372 board-hygiene tail) | +| D-REUNIFY-2 | 8-channel → SPO transcoder spec at thinking-engine L3 commit boundary | **Backlog** | per Option R-3; sprint-12+ | +| D-REUNIFY-3 | `Think` carrier struct prototype unifying thinking-engine cascade + cognitive-shader-driver SoA | **Backlog** | per `.claude/knowledge/splat-shader-rayon-struct-method-vision.md` sprint-12 | +| D-REUNIFY-4 | Splat op fleet (`splat_gaussian`, `score_hole_closure`, `replay_coherence`, `emit_if_epiphany`) as methods on `Think` | **Backlog** | sprint-13+ | +| D-REUNIFY-5 | rayon work-stealing par_* method variants | **Backlog** | sprint-14+ | +| D-REUNIFY-6 | OWL DOLCE / OntologyFilter wiring into `emit_causal_edges_filtered` | **Backlog** | sprint-15+ | + +--- + ## Update protocol When a deliverable ships: diff --git a/docs/TYPE_DUPLICATION_MAP.md b/docs/TYPE_DUPLICATION_MAP.md index e7347032..c8e495cb 100644 --- a/docs/TYPE_DUPLICATION_MAP.md +++ b/docs/TYPE_DUPLICATION_MAP.md @@ -167,6 +167,37 @@ Plus related types: **Impact**: Five different adjacency representations with no shared interface. **Epiphany**: All of these could implement a single `AdjacencyView` trait from the contract crate. +## 13. CausalEdge64 (Two Distinct Types, Same Name) + +**Two copies — and unlike #1-#12, these are NOT semantically equivalent variants of the same concept. Different bit layouts, different consumers, different roles. Surfaced 2026-05-14 in PR #372 meta-review.** + +| # | Location | Type Name | Layout | Role | +|---|----------|-----------|--------|------| +| 1 | `lance-graph/crates/causal-edge/src/edge.rs:60` | `CausalEdge64` (SPO-palette variant) | bits 0-7 S idx, 8-15 P idx, 16-23 O idx, 24-31 NARS frequency, 32-39 NARS confidence, 40-42 Pearl 2³ mask, 43-45 direction triad, 46-48 inference type, 49-51 plasticity, 52-63 temporal | NARS / Pearl / palette compose primitive; per-row payload of `cognitive-shader-driver::BindSpace::EdgeColumn`; used by `lance-graph-planner::cache::nars_engine`; commit unit at AriGraph SPO promotion | +| 2 | `lance-graph/crates/thinking-engine/src/layered.rs:45` | `CausalEdge64` (8-channel cascade variant) | 8 channels × 8 bits each: 0 BECOMES, 1 CAUSES, 2 SUPPORTS, 3 REFINES, 4 GROUNDS, 5 ABSTRACTS, 6 RELATES, 7 CONTRADICTS | Cascade dispatch payload between L1 (routing) → L2 (role resonance) → L3 (full thought) tier engines; emitted by `TierEngine::emit_causal_edges`; consumed by `TierEngine::apply_edges` | + +**Critical distinction — NOT a candidate for direct dedup:** + +These represent **different cognitive operations** rendered into the same u64 register width with the same name by coincidence (and lack of cross-crate review). The SPO variant carries (S, P, O, truth, mask, …) — self-contained statements. The 8-channel variant carries (target u16 separately) + 8 cognitive operators — strength vectors over a separate addressing. Source/target are **not** in the u64 for the 8-channel variant (`layered.rs:88-89`). + +**Drift origin:** `lance-graph/crates/lance-graph-planner/src/cache/convergence.rs:18-22` documents the intended unification ("CausalEdge64 intended for hot-path convergence wiring") via `#[allow(unused_imports)]` — wiring started, never finished. The 8-channel variant was reinvented locally in thinking-engine rather than imported from `causal-edge`. + +**Impact**: Same name in two crates is a footgun. Sprint-10 v2 work (`causaledge64-mailbox-rename-soa-v1`) targets the SPO-palette variant only; the 8-channel variant is out of scope. Future use of `CausalEdge64` must qualify by crate to avoid confusion. + +**Fix**: Reunification per Option R-3 (recommended) — keep both at their respective tiers; transcode 8-channel → SPO at the thinking-engine L3 commit boundary. Mapping per `.claude/knowledge/causal-edge-64-synergies-and-pr-trajectory.md` §6.3: +- BECOMES → `InferenceType::Synthesis` (transformative resonance) +- CAUSES → `InferenceType::Deduction` (forward chain) +- SUPPORTS → `InferenceType::Revision` positive (truth corroboration) +- REFINES → `InferenceType::Abduction` (specialization) +- GROUNDS → `InferenceType::Abduction` (foundational basis) +- ABSTRACTS → `InferenceType::Induction` (upward generalization) +- RELATES → `InferenceType::Synthesis` (lateral relation) +- CONTRADICTS → `InferenceType::Revision` negative (refutation, lowers c) + +Full design: `.claude/knowledge/causal-edge-64-spo-variant.md` + `.claude/knowledge/causal-edge-64-thinking-engine-variant.md` + `.claude/knowledge/causal-edge-64-synergies-and-pr-trajectory.md` + `.claude/knowledge/cognitive-shader-driver-thinking-engine-reunification.md`. + +--- + ## Summary: Duplication Heat Map ``` From 6ec63316417edf98bbd3583d7e91815377246b79 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Claude Date: Fri, 15 May 2026 19:29:06 +0000 Subject: [PATCH 2/2] fix(docs): align GROUNDS row in TYPE_DUPLICATION_MAP with canonical Option R-3 mapping MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit PR #374 review (chatgpt-codex-connector P2 catch): TYPE_DUPLICATION_MAP §13 mapped GROUNDS → InferenceType::Abduction, but the cited canonical source (.claude/knowledge/causal-edge-64-synergies-and-pr-trajectory.md §6.3 Option R-3) groups BECOMES / GROUNDS / RELATES → InferenceType::Synthesis. If a future sprint-12 transcoder were implemented from this summary, GROUNDS edges would commit with a different InferenceType than the canonical design — silent drift across two derivative references. Fix: change GROUNDS row to Synthesis matching the canonical source. Added an inline note that the semantic question (Synthesis vs Abduction for "foundational basis = abductive justification") is an open design question for the sprint-12+ transcoder spec — preserving the bot's catch as architectural future work rather than just hiding it. No other rows audited as drifted: CAUSES (Deduction), SUPPORTS (Revision+), REFINES (Abduction), ABSTRACTS (Induction), RELATES (Synthesis), CONTRADICTS (Revision-), BECOMES (Synthesis) all match the synergies doc. https://claude.ai/code/session_01UwJuKqP828qyX1VkLgGJFS --- docs/TYPE_DUPLICATION_MAP.md | 2 +- 1 file changed, 1 insertion(+), 1 deletion(-) diff --git a/docs/TYPE_DUPLICATION_MAP.md b/docs/TYPE_DUPLICATION_MAP.md index c8e495cb..f1bed865 100644 --- a/docs/TYPE_DUPLICATION_MAP.md +++ b/docs/TYPE_DUPLICATION_MAP.md @@ -189,7 +189,7 @@ These represent **different cognitive operations** rendered into the same u64 re - CAUSES → `InferenceType::Deduction` (forward chain) - SUPPORTS → `InferenceType::Revision` positive (truth corroboration) - REFINES → `InferenceType::Abduction` (specialization) -- GROUNDS → `InferenceType::Abduction` (foundational basis) +- GROUNDS → `InferenceType::Synthesis` (foundational basis — grouped with BECOMES + RELATES per canonical source; whether GROUNDS deserves a dedicated `InferenceType::Abduction` mapping for "foundational basis = abductive justification" semantics is an open design question for the sprint-12+ transcoder spec) - ABSTRACTS → `InferenceType::Induction` (upward generalization) - RELATES → `InferenceType::Synthesis` (lateral relation) - CONTRADICTS → `InferenceType::Revision` negative (refutation, lowers c)