diff --git a/VALIDATION.md b/VALIDATION.md index 8e472ed..da4c579 100644 --- a/VALIDATION.md +++ b/VALIDATION.md @@ -4,6 +4,21 @@ by this adapter yet. Nothing built on this repository may present model output as meaningful until this file records passing replications. +## Upstream queries + +Findings raised with the DEFINE authors on their own tracker, so the record +here and the record there stay in step: + +- [DEFINE_UK_1.1#1](https://github.com/DEFINE-model/DEFINE_UK_1.1/issues/1) — + which code vintage produced Model Manual v1.1 Table 4; the emissions path at + `846081a` runs below the published values. +- [DEFINE_UK_1.1#2](https://github.com/DEFINE-model/DEFINE_UK_1.1/issues/2) — + §3.3.2 uses six parameters absent from Table 5 (α₀GCFPS, α₀bNFF, α₁bNFF, + α₁CRPS, α₂CRPS, α₃CRPS) and two variables defined nowhere in the manual + (r_KNFF, r_KFF), so the section cannot be simulated forward as published; + plus Eq. (84) disagreeing with Table 6 by 3.04x and Eq. (61) contradicting + the stated fuel-price normalisation. + ## Standard Same bar as the suite's other replications (boe-var-model, us-hank-model):