PR_10_6V_final_dod_validation.md

PR 10.6V Final DoD Validation

Date: 2026-04-27 PR: 10.6V Build Doc: docs/pr/PR_10_6V_FINAL_DOD.md

Scope Executed

• Kept scope to Tool UI readiness enforcement only.
• No fallback/demo data added.
• No hardcoded sample paths introduced.
• Manifest-driven loading contracts preserved.

Minimal Implementation Deltas

• Updated diagnostics taxonomy support in tools/shared/toolLoadDiagnostics.js to include required classes:
  • success, missing, wrong-path, wrong-shape, empty, defaulted, disabled, unselected, lifecycle-reset
• Enforced first valid default selection in Asset Browser when approved assets exist:
  • tools/Asset Browser/main.js
• Tightened readiness classifications in required tools:
  • tools/Asset Browser/main.js
  • tools/Vector Asset Studio/main.js
  • tools/Vector Map Editor/editor/VectorMapEditorApp.js
  • tools/Sprite Editor/modules/spriteEditorApp.js

Required Validation Commands

1. npm run test:launch-smoke:games

• Result: PASS
• Evidence: PASS=12 FAIL=0 TOTAL=12

2. npm run test:sample-standalone:data-flow

• Result: PASS
• Evidence:
  • totalSampleToolPayloadFiles: 64
  • totalRoundtripRows: 64
  • schemaFailures: []
  • contractFailures: []
  • roundtripPathFailures: []
  • genericFailures: []

DoD Rule Validation

1. Global selectable-control rule: PASS

• Asset Browser now auto-selects first valid approved asset when no prior/shared selection exists.
• Vector Map Editor retains default first object selection behavior and diagnostics.
• Vector Asset Studio and Sprite Editor readiness diagnostics now explicitly classify unselected states.

2. Global control enablement rule: PASS

• Sprite Editor control diagnostics now differentiate disabled from missing/unselected when data is valid but controls remain disabled.
• Vector Map Editor selected-object readiness differentiates disabled controls from unselected state.

3. Global lifecycle/timer rule: PASS

• Lifecycle instability now reported as lifecycle-reset across in-scope tool readiness/final readiness diagnostics.
• No timer/fallback lifecycle reset behavior was introduced in this PR.

4. Empty-state rule: PASS

• Asset Browser preserves explicit empty-state messaging for loaded-empty/source-missing/source-wrong-shape conditions.
• No fabricated approved assets were introduced.

Tool-specific Acceptance

1. Vector Asset Studio: PASS

• Palette/paint/stroke readiness remains bound to loaded inputs.
• Missing selection states now classify as unselected; lifecycle instability classifies as lifecycle-reset.

2. Vector Map Editor: PASS

• Default object selection remains enforced when objects exist.
• Selected-object diagnostics now distinguish unselected vs disabled.

3. Asset Browser / Import Hub: PASS

• Default first approved-asset selection added.
• Selected preview/import readiness now report unselected when data exists but selection is absent.
• Empty-state/source-state behavior retained and explicit.

4. State Inspector: PASS (no 10.6V code change required)

• Existing 10.6U behavior remains in place: clear manual JSON guidance, no misleading initial blank-input failure state.

5. Sprite Editor sample 0219: PASS (no 10.6V code change required)

• Static expectation clarification from 10.6U remains intact.

UAT Gate Summary

• Missing required controls: 0 known (execution-backed checks show no contract/schema/path failures)
• Disabled controls with valid data: 0 known unresolved in scoped tools after readiness classification hardening
• Missing default selections with selectable data: 0 in scoped tool paths addressed by this PR
• Lifecycle/timer reset findings: 0 known unresolved in scoped diagnostics after lifecycle-reset alignment
• Unclear empty states: 0 known unresolved in scoped Asset Browser flows

Gate Decision: UAT READY (for PR 10.6V scope)