x of the dismissible boxes it not at the top-right corner

[damithc]

v2.8.0
Current:

Previous:

[ang-zeyu]

Hmm, it was actually an intentional decision I made when adding headings to boxes in MarkBind/vue-strap#116.

It looked a little strange packed when the heading is squashed with the close button in the top right to me, so I also applied the change to boxes without headings to maintain consistency.

Granted, its a subjective change. Should it be reverted?

[damithc]

How about if we keep it as high as possible? i.e., if there is no heading, it will be at the top. If there is a heading, it will be just below it (as shown in the screenshot).
Also, we can consider moving the heading to the left corner.

[ang-zeyu]

Also, we can consider moving the heading to the left corner.

Here's how it looks on the left:

And if the x is aligned with the flag instead of at the top right.

I think having the heading on the left gives a cleaner feel overall, and having the type-specific icon appear under the header is a welcome change ( since the header is likely tied to what the icon implies ).

But it would also mean no text wrapping around the header (since starting the content with a massive indent probably wouldnt be ideal), and a taller box overall.

How about if we keep it as high as possible? i.e., if there is no heading, it will be at the top. If there is a heading, it will be just below it (as shown in the screenshot).

On second look, this dosen't look too packed as well.

Any input? 😮

I prefer heading-left, and x aligned with flag personally

[damithc]

I prefer heading-left, and x aligned with flag personally

I prefer the heading-left, x on top as it is traditional to have window controls at the top-right corner.

On a separate matter, should we remove the background behind the heading? Or make he background span the entire box?

What happens if I use more formatting for the header e.g.,

<box>
<div slot="header">

### See here!
</div>
Coming soon...
</box>

[ang-zeyu]

I prefer the heading-left, x on top as it is traditional to have window controls at the top-right corner.

👍

On a separate matter, should we remove the background behind the heading? Or make he background span the entire box?

'Barebones' but looks unexpectedly good.

I think spanning the background across the entire width of the box ( if I didn't misinterpret ) would make it very similar in functionality and design to an expanded but unexpandable panel

Could also try a background that blends more inconspicuously with the original background

What happens if I use more formatting for the header e.g.,

<box>
<div slot="header">

### See here!
</div>
Coming soon...
</box>

I didn't implement md parsing for the box headings. 🤦‍♂ Will add it in as well.

But once it is there, I would suppose the background stays? ( if there's one )

[damithc]

Shall we go with this one then?

[ang-zeyu]

Shall we go with this one then?

👍

[damithc]

By the way, this the 'box with header' in MkDocs. I like it.

It's quite close to a panel, but a lot more convenient for authors, compared to configuring a panel to match this style exactly. Perhaps we can support a similar style if a header is supplied? Just a thought.

[ang-zeyu]

Looks nice 👍
Isn't too hard to morph from what I have either

On another note,

Heading indexing for boxes should be allowed for boxes right? ( the feature where if you use a custom h1 h2... h6 header or always-index class )
Or would that be out-of-scope? Since boxes are typically used for presenting bite-sized information

[damithc]

Heading indexing for boxes should be allowed for boxes right? ( the feature where if you use a custom h1 h2... h6 header or always-index class )
Or would that be out-of-scope? Since boxes are typically used for presenting bite-sized information

Depends on the cost. Ideally, should be allowed if not a lot of extra work. Our search relies on heading and we might want readers to be able to locate a box using search. But if the cost too high, we can disallow it.

[ang-zeyu]

Depends on the cost. Ideally, should be allowed if not a lot of extra work.

Hmm, should be rather cost-free when building since collectHeadingsAndKeywords already does it for <box> contents.
Just need to render each heading='...' with markdown-it, which is also being done for panels.

Search performance could be an issue either depending on the total number of headings in the site, but one could always use no-index to trim it down.
The search bar could also be optimized to do lazy searching in the future if it isn't already doing so, or have 'search categories' to limit the amount of data processed at every key press.

I'll try it out first eitherway. Thanks!