feat(safety): close SG-3..6 lifecycle gaps (v1.0.3 Track 4)#120
Conversation
Added 4 safety-context artifacts (SC-CTXT-2..5) scoping SG-3..6's applicability, plus 3 new safety-solution artifacts (SOL-6..8) supporting SG-4/5/6. After this commit, 'rivet validate' shows NO lifecycle-coverage gaps. The remaining 9 errors are pre-existing structural issues unrelated to v1.0.3 Track 4 scope: - SG-1..6 want explicit decomposition-via-strategy or a different link-type-from-SG-to-SOL than the existing 'supports' direction. Schema-fit issue, predates v1.0.0. - CP-1, CP-2, CP-3 use link type 'acted-on-by' not declared in schema. Predates v1.0.0. These are tracked for a separate schema-fit cleanup PR. The original goal (close the 4 SG-3..6 lifecycle gaps reported up through v1.0.2) is met. ## What ships SC-CTXT-2 → SG-3: verifier scope + external-tool assumptions SC-CTXT-3 → SG-4: determinism scope (compiler I/O, not runtime) SC-CTXT-4 → SG-5: Component Model interface preservation scope SC-CTXT-5 → SG-6: conservative-skip scope and observability SOL-6 → SG-6: per-pass revert counter + --stats surfacing SOL-7 → SG-4: byte-identical regression on canonical fixtures SOL-8 → SG-5: component-model post-fold validation Trace: REQ-3, REQ-14, REQ-15
Automated review for PR #120pulseengine/loom: Verdict: 🔴 Request changes Summary: Adds safety context and solutions to lifecycle gaps. Findings: 7 mechanical (rivet) · 0 from local AI model. Findings (7):
Generated by a local AI model and post-validated against a strict JSON contract. Each finding includes the verbatim line being criticised — verify by reading the file at the cited location. Reviewed at |
…ap) (#124) Five-track sprint. Three landed via agents in worktrees, one direct-work, one deferred when its agent died. Merged: #120 Track 4: close SG-3..6 lifecycle gaps #121 Track 1 (PR-Q): real corpus fixtures (3rd attempt — success) #122 Track 2: ægraph MVP (acyclic e-graph substrate) #123 Track 5: issue triage + roadmap doc Issues closed via the roadmap: #45 Rocq foundation (already shipped) #47 StackSignature::compose associativity (proven) #50 Crocus-style ISLE verification (already in verify_rules.rs) #75 P3 async callback trampolines (duplicate of #70) Deferred to v1.0.4: Track 3: verifier table-resolver teaching (agent died) ægraph rewrite engine + per-rule proofs KEEP issues #48 #68 #70 #71 Lifecycle gaps: 4 → 0 (track 4 closed all remaining).
1 participant
Closes all 4 remaining lifecycle gaps from v1.0.2 (
rivet validate). Adds 4 safety-context artifacts (SC-CTXT-2..5) and 3 safety-solutions (SOL-6..8). After merge, no 'Lifecycle coverage gaps' section appears in rivet validate output. The 9 remaining errors are pre-existing schema-fit issues (SG decomposition + CP link types) unrelated to this PR.🤖 Generated with Claude Code