Using MobX instead of Redux

[perrosnk]

Is anyone using Mobx instead of Redux? If yes, would it be possible to share some boilerplate?

[mastermoo]

+1

[miladebadi]

+1

[adamski]

Just started looking at MobX and I'd be interested in using it with RNN too..
+1

[adamski]

According to https://github.com/aksonov/react-native-mobx it is "framework free" so in theory should be able to use it with RNN as-is. I will try this soon...

[perrosnk]

If you could share a boilerplate if you manage to do it, it would be very helpful for the whole community I think!

[mastermoo]

@perrosnk @adamski @knot123 there u go... navigation-mobx-example.
It's based on this redux-example.

[mastermoo]

@guyca it would make sense, to add the mobX example to this repo, as well. What do u think?

[guyca]

@mastermoo Thanks for taking the initiative and making an example project. MobX sounds interesting and we're excited to hear you got navigation working with it. Are you using MobX with Navigation in production?

If it's ok with you, I'll link your project and this thread in the readme file. Adding another example project isn't feasable at this time, since we can't commit to another framework. We have a lot planned for the library and officially supporting another framework will add a lot of overhead.

[mastermoo]

Yes it's good with me.MobX is really a joy to use compared to redux. Yes, currently, I'm building a fairly complex app using Navigation and MobX. 😊Good to hear, that there is a lot planned for this library! I would really like to contribute to this repo, but I don't know any Objective C :/

    _____________________________

From: Guy Carmeli notifications@github.com
Sent: Sunday, August 14, 2016 12:47 AM
Subject: Re: [wix/react-native-navigation] Is it possible to use MobX instead of Redux? QUESTION
To: wix/react-native-navigation react-native-navigation@noreply.github.com
Cc: Yousef Kamawall yousef.kamawall@gmail.com, Mention mention@noreply.github.com

@mastermoo Thanks for taking the initiative and making an example project. MobX sounds interesting and we're excited to hear you got navigation working with it. Are you using MobX with Navigation in production?

If it's ok with you, I'll link your project and this thread in the readme file. Adding another example project isn't feasable at this time, since we can't commit to another framework. We have a lot planned for the library and adding officially supporting another framework will add a lot of overhead.

—
You are receiving this because you were mentioned.
Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub, or mute the thread.

[arstiefel]

+1

[vonovak]

+1

[maxs15]

+1

[DanielZlotin]

Great work @mastermoo !
One of the changes I have planned is to separate redux/mobx/other state containers from the core of this framework.

Optimally we would have the core Navigation, and on top of it (either another npm module completely or just a different module inside the framework) some wrappers that inject the state container logic into the screens.

For example you import react-native-navigation/redux or react-native-navigation/mobx instead of react-native-navigation.

This is just an idea right now as we have far more pressing concerns. In any case, this shouldn't be hard, and far more extensible. Can be assigned to milestone 2.1.0 I think.