Skip to content
Closed
Next Next commit
fix: issue #11947 automated patch
  • Loading branch information
t7r0n committed Mar 22, 2026
commit 40ffe0f23fb87de3ff88e1b53f16c3811883934f
37 changes: 37 additions & 0 deletions .bot/coordination/acceptance_criteria.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,37 @@
# Acceptance Criteria — Retry for issue #11947

## Source of truth for this retry
- [ ] Retry scope is derived from `.bot/validation_failures.md`
- [ ] Only required fixes tied to the recorded failure are included

## Files in scope
- [ ] `python-package/xgboost/__init__.py`
- [ ] `tests/python/test_shap.py`

## `python-package/xgboost/__init__.py`
- [ ] `interpret` is imported on its own line:
- `from . import interpret`
- [ ] `collective` remains on its own line:
- `from . import collective`
- [ ] `"interpret"` remains present in `__all__`
- [ ] Import layout is stable under ruff/pre-commit (no auto-rewrite on rerun)

## `tests/python/test_shap.py`
- [ ] No extra blank line remains between `import scipy.special` and `import xgboost as xgb`
- [ ] The interpret wrapper tests remain present in this file
- [ ] File formatting is stable under ruff/pre-commit (no auto-rewrite on rerun)

## Validation
### Required
- [ ] Exact failed command now passes:
- `pre-commit run --files python-package/xgboost/__init__.py tests/python/test_shap.py --show-diff-on-failure`

### Optional if environment supports it
- [ ] Narrow targeted test run for interpret wrapper coverage passes:
- `python -m pytest tests/python/test_shap.py -k "TestInterpret" -q`

## Scope discipline
- [ ] No unrelated files were edited for this retry
- [ ] `python-package/xgboost/interpret.py` was left unchanged unless a concrete follow-up error required touching it
- [ ] No docs, refactors, or broader API work were added in this retry
- [ ] No PRs were opened and no dangerous commands were run
86 changes: 86 additions & 0 deletions .bot/coordination/coordinator_plan.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,86 @@
# Coordinator Retry Plan — dmlc/xgboost issue #11947

## Goal of this retry
This retry is **not** a fresh implementation plan for the whole RFC. It is a **targeted retry** based strictly on the recorded validation failure in `.bot/validation_failures.md`.

## Failure summary
Only one required check failed:
- suite: `lint`
- command:
- `pre-commit run --files python-package/xgboost/__init__.py tests/python/test_shap.py --show-diff-on-failure`

The failure log shows that **ruff auto-fixed formatting/import layout** in exactly two files:
1. `python-package/xgboost/__init__.py`
2. `tests/python/test_shap.py`

No other required validation failures are recorded.

## What the failure means
The previous attempt already had the intended retry scope loaded into the linted files, but the patch did not land in a pre-commit-clean form.

### Exact hook-driven fixes from the log
#### `python-package/xgboost/__init__.py`
Ruff changed:
- from:
- `from . import collective`
- plus implicit/combined import arrangement
- to separate import lines:
- `from . import collective`
- `from . import interpret`

This means the retry must preserve **separate first-party import lines**, not collapse them.

#### `tests/python/test_shap.py`
Ruff changed:
- removed the extra blank line between:
- `import scipy.special`
- `import xgboost as xgb`

The file must keep normal import grouping with no stray blank line there.

## Retry scope
### Required edits only
Limit this retry to:
- `python-package/xgboost/__init__.py`
- `tests/python/test_shap.py`

### Explicitly avoid in this retry
Do **not** expand scope unless the exact failing command forces it.
In particular, do not spend this retry on:
- new docs
- new result classes
- new public methods on booster/sklearn models
- unrelated refactors
- new test files unless absolutely necessary

## Important repo state note
There is already a pending implementation file in the worktree:
- `python-package/xgboost/interpret.py`

That file is **not mentioned in the recorded failure**. The retry worker should treat it as already part of the patch and **avoid churning it** unless a follow-up validation step shows a concrete issue.

## Required retry actions
1. Ensure `python-package/xgboost/__init__.py` uses the ruff-compatible separate import line for `interpret`.
2. Ensure `tests/python/test_shap.py` matches the ruff-compatible import spacing.
3. Keep the new interpret wrapper tests in `tests/python/test_shap.py`; do not move them elsewhere during this retry unless unavoidable.
4. Re-run the exact failing command:
- `pre-commit run --files python-package/xgboost/__init__.py tests/python/test_shap.py --show-diff-on-failure`

## Optional follow-up validation (only if inexpensive and available)
If the environment supports Python/native test execution, run a narrow targeted test for the newly added interpret wrapper coverage inside `tests/python/test_shap.py`.
Suggested example:
- `python -m pytest tests/python/test_shap.py -k "TestInterpret" -q`

If that is not feasible, the exact pre-commit pass is sufficient for this retry plan.

## Success definition for this retry
This retry succeeds when:
- the exact failing pre-commit command passes cleanly
- no additional unrelated edits are introduced
- the worker leaves the patch focused on the already-implemented interpretability slice

## Main risks to avoid
- Re-expanding scope beyond the logged failure
- Moving tests into a different file during the retry
- Collapsing imports in `__init__.py` back into a form ruff rewrites
- Touching `interpret.py` without a concrete failure signal
6 changes: 6 additions & 0 deletions .bot/coordination/worker_handoff.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,6 @@
# Worker Handoff

Issue #11947 (initial)
- Apply minimal scoped patch only.
- Update tests relevant to changed behavior.
- Write .bot/pr_body.md and .bot/coordination/worker_report.md.
108 changes: 108 additions & 0 deletions .bot/coordination/worker_handoff_retry.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,108 @@
# Worker Handoff Retry — GPT-5.3-Codex

## Context
This is a **retry handoff**, not a greenfield implementation brief.
You must scope your work to the recorded validation failure in:
- `.bot/validation_failures.md`

Read that file first if you need to confirm the failure context.

## Failure to fix
Only one required check failed:

```bash
pre-commit run --files python-package/xgboost/__init__.py tests/python/test_shap.py --show-diff-on-failure
```

The failure log shows `ruff check` auto-modified these two files.

## Exact required changes from the failure log
### 1) `python-package/xgboost/__init__.py`
Ruff wanted this import layout:

```python
from . import tracker # noqa
from . import collective
from . import interpret
```

Do **not** collapse `collective` and `interpret` into one import line.
Keep them as separate `from . import ...` statements.

Also keep `"interpret"` in `__all__`.

### 2) `tests/python/test_shap.py`
Ruff removed one extra blank line in the import section.
The top of the file should look like:

```python
import itertools
import re

import numpy as np
import scipy.special
import xgboost as xgb
from xgboost import testing as tm
```

Do not leave a stray blank line between `scipy.special` and `import xgboost as xgb`.

## Scope constraints
### Only touch what is required by this retry
Focus on:
- `python-package/xgboost/__init__.py`
- `tests/python/test_shap.py`

### Do not expand scope
Do **not** use this retry to:
- redesign the API
- move tests into a new file unless absolutely forced
- add docs
- add new methods to booster/sklearn wrappers
- refactor unrelated code
- touch unrelated files because they “look nicer”

## Important current state
There is already a pending implementation file in the worktree:
- `python-package/xgboost/interpret.py`

That file was **not** part of the failing lint command. Assume it is already part of the intended patch and **leave it alone unless a concrete error requires a change**.

## What to preserve
The retry should preserve the already-added interpret wrapper coverage in `tests/python/test_shap.py`.
Do not remove those tests. The retry is about making the existing patch pass the exact failed validation.

## Recommended step-by-step
1. Inspect current diffs/status.
2. Ensure `python-package/xgboost/__init__.py` matches the ruff-preferred import layout.
3. Ensure `tests/python/test_shap.py` import spacing matches the ruff-preferred layout.
4. Do not make unrelated edits.
5. Run the exact failed validation command:
```bash
pre-commit run --files python-package/xgboost/__init__.py tests/python/test_shap.py --show-diff-on-failure
```
6. If that passes and the environment is healthy enough, optionally run a narrow targeted test:
```bash
python -m pytest tests/python/test_shap.py -k "TestInterpret" -q
```

## Expected end state
- `python-package/xgboost/__init__.py`:
- separate import line for `interpret`
- `"interpret"` remains in `__all__`
- `tests/python/test_shap.py`:
- clean import spacing
- interpret wrapper tests still present
- exact pre-commit command passes without rewriting files

## Non-goals
- No PR creation
- No pushes
- No dangerous commands
- No broad cleanup pass

## Deliverable quality bar
This retry is successful only if it is:
- minimal
- directly tied to the logged failure
- pre-commit clean for the exact failing command
44 changes: 44 additions & 0 deletions .bot/coordination/worker_report.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,44 @@
# Worker Report: issue #11947 (`repair-2`)

## Status
- Completed

## Scope executed
- Read required context files:
- `AGENTS.md`
- `.bot/retrieved_memory.md`
- `.bot/memory/worker_retrieved_memory.md`
- `.bot/coordination/worker_handoff_retry.md`
- `.bot/validation_failures.md`
- Kept retry scope tied to the single recorded failure:
- `pre-commit run --files python-package/xgboost/__init__.py tests/python/test_shap.py --show-diff-on-failure`

## Concrete remediation notes
1. `python-package/xgboost/__init__.py`
- Confirmed/import layout aligned with ruff-stable form:
- `from . import collective`
- `from . import interpret`
- Confirmed `"interpret"` remains in `__all__`.

2. `tests/python/test_shap.py`
- Confirmed no extra blank line remains between:
- `import scipy.special`
- `import xgboost as xgb`
- Preserved the previously added `TestInterpret` coverage (no removal or relocation).

## Validation run for retry
- Required command:
- `pre-commit run --files python-package/xgboost/__init__.py tests/python/test_shap.py --show-diff-on-failure`
- Result: Pass
- Additional check:
- `python -m py_compile python-package/xgboost/interpret.py tests/python/test_shap.py python-package/xgboost/__init__.py`
- Result: Pass
- Optional targeted test attempt:
- `PYTHONPATH=python-package python -m pytest tests/python/test_shap.py -k "TestInterpret" -q`
- Result: Blocked (`ModuleNotFoundError: No module named 'numpy'`)

## Scope discipline confirmation
- No retry-scope expansion beyond the recorded lint failure.
- `python-package/xgboost/interpret.py` left unchanged in this pass.
- No docs/refactors/extra API work added during retry.
- No PRs were opened.
Loading
Loading